Pin It

Planters Punch 1

Rum Punch: An Ancient Drink Fit For A Country's Birthday

With the 4th of July just around the corner many are already planning their backyard festivities--probably composed of something on the grill and a variety of alcohol. After all, what's more American than a burger and a Bud on the lawn, right? But (yawn) hasn't that been done before?

Instead of the old standby why don’t you make this year's party both memorable and traditional by creating a batch of one of the most American of drinks: rum punch.


For some,the name “Rum Punch” might quickly create visions of a vibrantly colored drink mingling sickly sweet flavors, syrupy ingredients and served garnished with fruit and umbrellas. Or maybe It was something you made in college in an empty ice chest with frozen limeade, orange slices and the cheapest rum Albertsons had available (yes, there’s a bit of personal narrative to this).

What you picture is probably not what you'd pick as a traditional Colonial drink. But you may be surprised to learn that the Rum Punch is steeped in centuries of history.

In the pirate infested Caribbean of the late 1600’s, pirates and sailors alike were known to be extremely fond of the beverage, which was popular in part due to the tendency of beer to go bad in warmer climates.  It was often the object of a pirate’s plundering and one legend tells of a buccaneer who sold his wife to get his hands on some of the drink.

But no place may the drink have been more celebrated than in Colonial America.  

The early colonists brought with them their own traditions and tastes, including many different recipes for Rum Punch which were shared and modified over time. Even our beloved founding fathers enjoyed a good Rum Punch (both Benjamin Franklin and George Washington had there own recipes for the popular drink which can still be found today).

In fact, our founding fathers enjoyed Rum Punch so much that on the night of September 17th 1787, at The City Tavern in Philadelphia, they threw a massive party in celebration of finally signing the U.S. Constitution.  During the party they  consumed, in addition to mass quantities of wine, spirits and beer,  a total of 14 large bowls of punch between a mere 55 revelers and 16 musicians (an additional 2% was added to the bill for damages).

So why was Rum Punch so popular in Colonial America?  Part of the reason had to do with the lack of refrigeration.  During the period refrigeration was unheard of and ice was an uncommon luxury.  As such fruit spoiled quickly and it was common practice to use the nearly spoiled fruit to make either Rum Punch or shrub (shrub is a vinegar syrup or fruit flavored liqueur made from fruit juices and/or rinds and  used to preserve the fruits in liquid form to be used later in Rum Punch or other alcoholic beverage).  Very little was wasted during the period and Rum Punch was a means to see all that fruit was used.

It was also considered a social drink.  Weaker than a simple spirit, the Punch encouraged interaction as revelers and party goers made multiple trips to the bowl for refills.  Upon each trip one would interact with someone different than a previous trip.  This made the drink popular at celebrations and festivals across the nation.

In short, when you drink a Rum Punch, you’re drinking with some of the most celebrated people from our past. It is a drink deserving of your Fourth of July celebration.

So how do you make Rum Punch today?  Recipe variations abound with the number amassing into the thousands.  Below are two examples based on two of the most historic recipes, the Bajan Recipe (often considered the oldest) and the Planter’s Recipe (which is believed to have been created in the U.S.)


Planters Punch Recipe based on the International Bartenders Association (IBA) official recipe


1.5 oz Dark Rum (Myers or similar)

.75 oz Lemon Juice

1 oz Orange Juice

1 oz Pineapple Juice

.33 oz Grenadine

.33 oz Simple Syrup

Aromatic Bitters


Combine all ingredients except Bitters over ice, shake, pour into a highball glass filled with ice, add 2-3 dashes bitters, garnish with fruit of your choice (lemon, lime, pineapple and/or cherry work great.)

Bobby Flay’s Rum Punch Recipe

Based on the Bajan Punch which states: 1 part sour, 2 parts sweet, 3 parts strong and 4 parts weak.


1 cup fresh lime juice

2 cups grenadine syrup

2 cups Jamaican white rum

1 cup light rum

2 cups fresh pineapple juice

2 cups fresh orange juice

Pinch freshly grated nutmeg, optional

Orange slices, for garnish

Pineapple slices, for garnish


Mix all ingredients together in a pitcher or punch bowl. Chill in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour before serving. Garnish with orange or pineapple slices.

So this 4th of July if you find yourself in Philadelphia stop by the City Tavern and enjoy a period Rum Punch influenced drink like The Shrub or Tavern Cooler in the same place our founding fathers partied it up.  If not, grab one of the provided recipes, whip it up for that 4th of July BBQ and enjoy a drink in homage to the great men who founded this great nation.  Remember, this drink is older than most distilled spirits or beers, our founding fathers drank it and pirates raided and pillaged over it....not such the girly drink we all tend to think it is.

Pin It